Rate My Look- indoor & outdoor

Here's another indoor/outdoor set of looks for you guys and gals. You know that's why I love winter- 2 completely different outfits in one day! First, the indoor:

Dress: Walmart, $18

Shoes: BCF, $19.99

Necklace: H&M $8 or $9- I forget the exact amount

Tights: Target, $6

And in case I get chilly at work, I can always layer on my favorite black cardigan:

And now for the outdoor look:

Coat: BCF, too long ago to know what it cost

Hat: Also BCF, $6.99

Brooch: Once again, too long ago to know what it cost

In this option, I put the brooch on the hat instead for a different look:

It's a tough call with this hat. I think there's a fine line between Dr. Zhivago and Dr. Seuss. I hope this one errs on the Dr. Zhivago side.

Personally, I prefer the hat with the brooch on it as opposed to the coat. What do you think? Is it ridiculous? Or perfectly appropriate for this time of year? I like it.